Which SW would fit me better?

[Iolaus]

A few months ago, I bought and returned a Stillwater HW, mostly because of concerns with how hot it would be in So.Cal. (I didn't realize how heavy "heavy" was.) While I had it, I noted that I had to have it at the outside notch on the straps, meaning it was just barely big enough. That was a 36".

I finally decided to get a standard model and, figuring that it would fit better, ordered a 38".

On the tightest notch, it feels a bit loose.

My question is, would the thickness of the previous kilt have affected the measurement so that comparison for size would be invalid? Would a 36" Standard fit differently than HW? Should I go ahead and send this back for a 36"?

I know some have said that altering size is a relativly simple task, but sewing isn't something I know anything about, so if thats the answer, are there any recomendations for an experienced tailor in OC Ca.?

[jjoseph]

... ordered a 38"....On the tightest notch, it feels a bit loose.

...would the thickness of the previous kilt have affected the measurement so that comparison for size would be invalid? Would a 36" Standard fit differently than HW? Should I go ahead and send this back for a 36"?

...some have said that altering size is a relativly simple task, but sewing isn't something I know...

I have a few Stills (two heavies, a standard and an econo)... the heavyweights have the hips sewn down and that makes them fit the waist an inch or so smaller than the standard, so my 36" heavy fits the same as my 34" Standard, so I order one size up for the heavies. When in doubt, go with the larger size; if it really is a bit too big, you can have any decent seamstress (most drycleaners have one on retainer as do most bridal outlets) alter it by moving the buckles over (should cost less than $15.00).

Remember you can alway make one smaller, but ya can't add fabric to make them bigger!