Opinions, please

[wvpiper]

OK-so I'd like your opinions on the kilt belt and the vest. I bought both of them today, tags still on, still have receipts if I need to return them (I see the kilt is out of kilter, I am alone watching kids, had to set the camera timer, in a rush so I could the kids to bed etc etc)--
EDIT: I'm not concerend some much about the overall look, I would like to know if the waiscoat and belt should be 'keepers'
The waistcoat came from Target, it's cotton with herringbone pattern, $25
The belt was $7 at Walmart, from the women's accesory dept-I got the idea to check there from another xmarker whose wife got him one
in the ladies dept.

http://share.shutterfly.com/share/re...2f12eb75ef82b5

[piperdbh]

I like them both, but not together. The vest hides the belt. I really like the vest with the polo shirt, however.

[McMurdo]

The waistcoat looks like it is getting caught up with the sporran a bit, I agree with piperdbh, a good rule is if you are wearing a belt no waistcoat and vice versa.

[Mael Coluim]

I think the belt distracts from your sporran. The vest looks fine. As you said not with the kilt you show.

[wvpiper]

The waistcoat looks like it is getting caught up with the sporran a bit, I agree with piperdbh, a good rule is if you are wearing a belt no waistcoat and vice versa.

I had to 'fold' the bottom of the waistcoat under in order to show the sporran.
I'm not really concerned about the overall look, as I said I was in a hurry, and so on.
I just wonder if the belt and waistcoat are 'keepers'?

The waistcoat is a Target waistcoat, cotton with herringbone pattern, $25.
The belt is off the women's rack at Walmart-$7. I got the idea from another Xmarker whose wife bought him a woman's belt.

[MacMillan of Rathdown]

For $32 I'd keep 'em both and wear 'em... but not at the same time.

[JolyStNicholas]

I agree! Keep them both. Wear them separately! Good fine!

[kiltedsawyer]

The vest is fine, but may need some alteration to sweep away from the sporran. The belt on the other hand, .....doesn't seem to mesh with the sporran, (which I really like.) I'd take the belt back and get something simpler that doesn't compete with the sporran.
Just MHO.

David

[attworth]

I like the vest, but agree you should probably alter it more permanently. Looks to be slightly bulging.

The belt is nice, but I agree, doesn't seem to quite work with that wonderful sporran.

[Dan R Porter]

My first belt was also from the womens dept.