What do you think?

[Tommy Hunt]

My wife just finished this amazing Aran sweater for me and although I love it and it's super comfy I'm wondering if it's a bit too much sweater for me. What do you guys think - too much? - look silly wearing it? - large but acceptable? great looking? Let me know, thanks.

[Cowher]

Yup waaaay to big for you. It will however look dashing on me. I'll pm you my address to take it off of you hands.
Seriously though I think it's bulky but in a really good way. I think that's one h3!! Of a sweater. You lady has skills. Does she do kilt hose?

I would however look in to a new kilt. The kilt you are wearing in these pictures in my opinion looks dreadful. Almost like P@NTS

[auld argonian]

Perhaps a careful washing and maybe it'll shrink a bit?

Best

AA

[Jock Scot]

What do I think? Its a tad too large for you and would almost certainly fit me a treat. Its super!

[theborderer]

Wonderful pattern, Nice colour BUT, yes it is a bit too big. Washing it may help but could also ruin the hang of it.

[Jack Daw]

I think it's fine and not too big. Just be careful at dinner that you watch the sleeves don't go into the pasta fagioli when you reach for the salt.

[MacMillan of Rathdown]

Does she accept commissions? (How's that for approval? )

[starbkjrus]

Does she accept commissions? (How's that for approval? )

+1

[Mike_Oettle]

Nice bit of knitting, Tommy. Very like the sweater and cardigan my mother-in-law made for me once upon a time.
My salaams to your good lady.
Regards,
Mike

[Spartan Tartan]

I think it's a wonderful looking sweater. It would look great with my kilt Ok...I just had to do it too.

It might look nice over top of a shirt and perhaps a tie to fill in a bit more. I have one similar (but not anywhere near as nice) that I wear all the time. Real comfortable.