Inspiration

**Ancienne Alliance** · 12th January 10, 04:10 AM

This one was my main inspiration in making my white cockade.

From http://www.circleofgentlemen.org/

Best,

Robert

**Woodsheal** · 12th January 10, 02:50 PM

That is one impressive cockade, for sure (as is yours, Rob!). However, the fellow should lose the Dark Ages penannular brooch....

**Highlander31** · 13th January 10, 04:53 AM

That is an impressive cockade. Robert, are you a member of the Circle of Gentlemen?

**Lyle1** · 13th January 10, 06:00 AM

Originally Posted by Woodsheal

That is one impressive cockade, for sure (as is yours, Rob!). However, the fellow should lose the Dark Ages penannular brooch....

So, what exactly is wrong with the brooch? I rather like penannular brooches, and I think that the gentleman is wearing a particularly nice on. I haven't seen many done in silver and with as much depth or thickness as the one he is wearing. The picture is a bit fuzzy, but there is also a hint of some fine metal working.

**Woodsheal** · 13th January 10, 07:35 AM

Originally Posted by Lyle1

So, what exactly is wrong with the brooch? I rather like penannular brooches, and I think that the gentleman is wearing a particularly nice on. I haven't seen many done in silver and with as much depth or thickness as the one he is wearing. The picture is a bit fuzzy, but there is also a hint of some fine metal working.

The problem is that the subject is dressed in ca. 1745 Jacobite garb, and penannular brooches fell out of use in the early Middle Ages....

**Tobus** · 13th January 10, 08:26 AM

Is he wearing a sash?

**Woodsheal** · 13th January 10, 09:05 AM

Originally Posted by Tobus

Is he wearing a sash?

I'd say a smallish shoulder plaid....

**Ancienne Alliance** · 13th January 10, 11:14 AM

I am a member of the Circle of gentlemen's public forum :

http://circleofgentlemen.forumup.com/

I read somewhere that this particular gentlemen, Mr Corby, describes his garb as neo-romantic Jacobite, nineteenth century celtic revival... with a personal touch.

Not exactly reenactor.

Best,

Robert

**NorCalPiper** · 13th January 10, 01:45 PM

Those hose look familiar.....hmmmm

**Redshank** · 13th January 10, 02:12 PM

here is possibly a better photo of the man in question, taken at Culloden memorial service last year

I don't see there being a problem with the penannular brooch, things like that where handed down from father to son, and it's perfectly suited for the use to which it is being put.