three choices

**Nick the DSM** · 7th October 07, 10:30 AM

ok, for a few months now i have been looking for a second kilt to wear. i have come up with three choices.
1. a casual kilt from scottishclansman.com 250 bucks, morrsion red modern
2. maybe 6 yards of morrison material and make a traditional great kilt out of that. i think the price would be around 400, right?
3. at the celtic croft, a 5 yard great kilt for about 400 bucks.

what do you think? i really want a morrison because its my families' and i need another kilt to wear and display my tartan too. i also need to know if a great kilt is really functional at all, a casual would be great to just put on and go, though a great kilt comes with the extra material to make a hood or something for when it rains(if ever, darn drought!). any help is appreciated. thank you for your time.

nick

**beloitpiper** · 7th October 07, 10:43 AM

Great kilts are antiquated and cumbersome. Unless wearing them for reenacting or costume (*ducks from Halloween thread*), I'd recommend a modern kilt every time.

A question for you, what drew you to scottishclansman.com? Why did you choose them?

**Riverkilt** · 7th October 07, 11:18 AM

Aye,

Clansman Knitwear (scottishclansman.com) has a fine website and many customers on this board. You may wish to do a Search on this site to review the threads about their products and service.

Best part of this forum for shoppers is ye olde search feature.

Kilt up!

Ron

**McMurdo** · 7th October 07, 11:22 AM

I would say go for the modern kilt, great kilts are out of place in the modern world, people do (rightly or wrongly) equate them to a costume. I am sure you will find more occasion to wear the modern than the great kilt. Good luck with your choice whatever it may be.

**gilmore** · 7th October 07, 11:25 AM

I agree with the above. The great kilt would probably lie folded up in a drawer and get little use.

**BEEDEE** · 7th October 07, 11:50 AM

Don't know about scottishclanmen but if you are going to spend $250 or more, take a look at Rocky's (USA Kilts) semi-traditional kilts.

Brian

**Chef** · 7th October 07, 12:01 PM

For what you are will to spend on fabric or a great kilt you have a lot of choices in modern kilts. Check some our supporters. Since you want wool most kiltmakers can get the tartan you want.

I do agree with those above, stay with the modern kilt unless you expect a lot of visits to renfairs and the like. It isn't really a sensible garment for everyday wear.

**O'Neille** · 7th October 07, 12:05 PM

I'd do a search of the kilt makers on the board. Pay special attention to their customer service (search threads) and then see if they can accmodate your Morrison needs. O'Neille

**Roan Carter** · 7th October 07, 03:58 PM

You can always turn your great kilt into a regular kilt by folding it in half before you make the pleats, unless you have too much fabric ... like 7 or 8 yards. Then just use a second belt to hold down the extra fabric afterwards. I do this often times, and posted pics of it on my site. For a more casual look, you can pull your shirt down over the belt.

http://www.angelfire.com/scifi/p3/Kilts.html

**Nick the DSM** · 7th October 07, 04:34 PM

ok, so a casual kilt would be better than a great, sounds fine i was leaning toward a casual kilt anyways.

i had gotten the idea of clansman from the highland games i went to, they has a tent and i grabbed a card. i looked at it and it looks good. reason i like them is that they arent really expensive and they have a great selection.

i'll go check the usa kilt place out.

thanks

nick

EDIT: i looked at the usa kilt, wow expensive. i think i'll go with scottsihclansman.