Don't get caught up in the 8-yard thing. It's more a label than anything as the amount of material varies by the size of the wearer and if it is pleated to the sett or stripe. It could use as little as 5, as much as 9. Don't overlook other options such as a more casual model or a 4 yard box pleat. Matt Newsome has a nice history of those on his site. While there are those who will say you can't even call it a kilt unless it's 8+ yards of Scottish tartan, it's up to you. I love tartan but have come to appriciate solid colors as they are very versital. Try wearing a Hawaiian shirt with tartan...looks silly.

Explore your options. Consider what you do and where you go. Keep your style and personality in mind too. I, personally, wouldn't wear a kilt that's about $300 to the pub. It's a little too dressy in my mind, and there is too much potential for damage or a sudden need to get it cleaned. I also wouldn't wear one of my off the shelf Stillwaters to a wedding as they are more like a pair of jeans in my mind. And don't count out PV either as it's less expensive, can be machine washed, and still has a very good hang and swing. The only downside is a limited selection of tartans.

I think the 3 best places to buy in the US are USA Kilts, Skye Highland Outfitters, and Stillwater Kilts. I've yet to deal with Frugal Corner, but I have heard good things.


This is a discussion that is probably going on at all times somewhere on this site.