Traditional - Red Deer? vs US deer/Elk leathers

[Mule]

I hope I got this in the correct area.

Since I'm just starting to learn leather craft, I am researching everything I can. One of the problems I have come up against is the types of leather we have here in the US that are readily available VS traditional leathers from Scotland and how nobody I have found deals with the topic...

I did some research on it and found it very eye opening, at least for me. This may be old news, but I didn't find it in any of the searches here. I may just be daft though.

The first question is this, is most of the traditional Scottish leather items made from the Red Deer? I can't tell for sure. If not, then this whole thing is just scientific twaddle.

Next thing is the actual scientific classification of each. Oddly enough, the Elk/Wapiti is very close.
Kingdom down to Family are all the same. With Family being Cervidae. From there the classifications go to Sub family, Genus and Species.

Here is the boring/fun stuff.
Sub family; US deer(White and Mule) W & M - Capreolinae. Red AND Elk - Cervinae.

Genus; USD W & M - Odocoileus. Red AND Elk - Cervus.

Species; USD W - O. Virginianus, M - O. Hemionus. Red - C. Elephus (funny name) and Elk - C. Canadensis.


The questions this leaves me with are these;
Does Elk and Red leathers have the same grain pattern?
Are the natural colors the same when tanned?
Is the thickness and feel the same?

[Burly Brute]

I totally saw this on fbook first! Lol, thought I would chime in, although I don't have an answer. I would guess you have to go by what was available at the time?

[Mule]

Yeah, his post got me to thinking more about it. I'm kind of uptight about things sometime.

Probably on the availability, but since the Elk is pretty cheap and nice to work with, it's a real bonus. And, I don't have a big stash of leather/hide yet...

Look at these pictures, amazing similarity isn't it.

[Burly Brute]

Yea, it seems the biggest difference is in their lower jaw/neck.

[Mule]

Agreed. The racks look much the same. Which is nice. I have two 5x5 junk elk racks that I am going to use for buttons, handles ect... If I have to opportunity to be period correct I will take it.

[Joe Gondek]

red deer are also found over the rest of europe
the german tan leather is german elk(red deer)

[Mule]

Great. Thanks Joe!
I did not realize that. I almost bought some German leather yesterday but couldn't get my instructor friend on the phone... I don't start class with him for another week.

[AKScott]

I have never worked red deer.

I have worked quite a few domestic leathers. If/when you are comfortable with a few weights of cowhide, elk (you already got) maybe pigskin and something really soft like kid goat, all of which are relatively inexpensive well; at that point you should be OK ordering likely more expensive authentic red deer hide.

I would weigh heavily any contribution artificer makes to this thread, he has worked with a greater variety of leather than I.

[Ryan Ross]

Lamar Britt talks about the Elk vs. Red Deer thing all the time. And I know that he works extensively with North American Elk, and that he has worked with Scottish Red Deer also.

I'll ask him how simmilar he finds the hides, next time I talk to him.