I love the look of the MacDougall Heritage but when I ordered my "tank" last summer the kiltmaker (MacIsaac in Cape Breton) wasn't familiar with the fabric that was then available so I decided on MacDougall Modern. I love it. I also have a box-pleated in MacDougall Ancient just made by John at Keltoi. I love it too. Bit of a Sophie's Choice situation but if pushed I would have to say that the Ancient colours are now my preference. I also saw a swatch of MacDougall muted and it was pretty sharp too.