I've narrowed it down to a Stillwater standard in either the Nightwatch or Nightstalker tartan or a Pittsburgh Kilts model in brushed twill.

I'm leaning to the modern kilt at the moment. I think that it might be more appropriate for how I'm likely to wear it at the moment and I'd like to support a local maker.

In any event, I'll probably get the other for my second kilt (if it comes to that).