Tono,

When you say "the Campbells at Culloden", are you referring to Glencoe? There were Campbells at Culloden on both sides (mostly in the Argyll militia on the Government side, but there were some Campbells who fought for the Jacobites as well), but one thing should be pointed out -- neither the defeat of the Jacobites at Culloden nor the massacre of Glencoe were ordered and executed by Campbells exclusively. For the former, it was a British Army force, led by the Duke (Butcher) Cumberland, and for the latter, while there was a Campbell in command at Glencoe, Robert Campbell of Glenlyon, his force was made up of soldiers, not Campbell clansmen per se.

Regards,

Todd