I say go with your gut and you cant go wrong. Which ever tartan you pick you know you are getting a quality kilt from Rocky and Kelly. Now, if it were me, I'd probably pick a Black Watch. Its a "universal" tartan that never seems out of place - but that's me and not you.

Whatever you decide, be sure to show us some photos when you get it - that way we can all congratulate you on such a smart decision!