My first was a Amerikilt i purchased long before i knew much about the others.I liked it an soon bought another.
Pretty much casual kilts and only come in about five different solid colors.

My third was an Irish National from Stillwater Kilts.Very nice formal,and very reasonable price.

My fourth an fifth were kilts i made myself,and did'nt turn out to bad for my first try.

I plan on ordering an American Heritage and a US Army kilt from USA kilts if Rocky ever gets back from where ever hes hiding out.LOL
Seems i read they won't be processing orders until after the 25th of January.
I think you can still order,but i'm going to wait untill next month.No hurry anyway,but would like to get them before spring break.

I would listen to the advice of these great guys in here before you make your decision on what you want to purchase.

I also like using KiltDay.com for links to good Kilt sites.
Saves you from searching all over the web.
Thats where i came across this great group and i'm glad i did.