That question is pretty much impossible to answer.

Personally, what drew me to the idea of wearing a kilt was seeing the fiddler in the Celtic rock band, "Tempest" wearing a black Utilikilt. However, what I bought, first was a Stillwater Standard in Black Watch. That is by no means traditional, but it IS tartan, and to the uninitiated, it certainly looks like a traditional kilt. I think each person is different, so I didn't vote.