Diced Tam and Cap Badge?

[Ryan Ross]

...Just don't wear a tartan or re-enactor's bonnet with Highland attire...

I completely respect your oppinion on this matter, good sir, but would still like to pose a question to the traditionalists:

Would the below bonnet strike you as inappropriate for modern wear in a traditional setting? Might it stand out in any meaningful way, to your eye, or look like a "re-enactor's bonnet"? I'm really quite curious.

[MacMillan of Rathdown]

I completely respect your oppinion on this matter, good sir, but would still like to pose a question to the traditionalists:

(1) Would the below bonnet strike you as inappropriate for modern wear in a traditional setting?

No. It's perfectly acceptable.

(2) Might it stand out in any meaningful way, to your eye, or look like a "re-enactor's bonnet"?

It looks just fine, and unless you were also carrying a Brown Bess musket no one would think you were a re-enactor.

I'm really quite curious.

Nothing wrong with that.