tie with a prince charlie?

[Lyle1]

A PC when worn with a 4 in hand looks better with a 5 button waistcoat. But not traditionally correct. Of course I got run off from the traditional forum so just ignore me... like this: http://buyakilt.com/silver-prince-charlie-kilt-outfit
Rondo

I was thinking the same thing after seeing the photos earlier in the thread. A long tie, even a ruche tie, simply does not look good with a low cut vest; the prorportin is off, and the tie looks like it is trying to escape! Even with a tux, the people I've seen wearing a four-in-hand-tie were wearing a five or more button vest with it.