Too Traditional?

[creagdhubh]

I think one needs to exert a tadd of common sense with THCD and the cromach is a useful example.

For some, on some occasions, the cromach is a necessary prop(in a theatrical sense). The Clan Chief on show ,for example.

For some, a cromach is a necessary prop (in a literal sense). A chap with shrapnel in his hip, for example.

For some, on occasion a cromach is a useful tool. Walking across moor and stream, for example.

For some, on occasion the cromach is an unnecessary affectation and therefore of doubtful traditional value.

Judgement and yes, experience, is the key to much of the appropriateness for kilt attire.

Agreed.