Rufus,

I have the St.Gall design in black, and the Lichfield in dark brown. I would suggest the Lichfield (which is the one Bear carries) over the St.Gall. It seems to have a lot more deatil, and looks great with a kilt. The St.Gall loses some of it's detail (especially in black). These are great belts, and I would suggest them to anyone. The 1 1/2 width is nice shorter than a usual kilt belt, but the belts go really well in a casual and formal setting.