Have had AmeriKilts. Owner Mike Butler(?) is a great guy. Good starter kilt. Cotton though so tends to wrinkle. Never bought a Buzz Kidder kilt because I never saw one for sale at a highland games that wasn't wrinkled up. Guessing from these two choices you're looking to buy an inexpensive kilt. In the kilt world its worth saving up and buying quality and value. Take a look at RKilts, and Utilikilts, and Freedom Kilts too.