Nice boots but wouldn't know how they might look with a kilt until tried on with a kilt. I recently bought a pair of boots I thought I'd really like (I do) but they don't particularly look right to me with a kilt -- thought they would, but they just didn't "feel/look right" to me with the kilt. That's the only way I know of to make sure. What feels right to some may not to others and that's fine. If you are comfortable with them (both fit and looks), what else matters?