My vote would go to the sporran on bears site. Having said that the second sporran you have chosen is almost the same as I have myself.One of the reasons I have made my own sporran is that shop purchased sporrans often don't open so wide and therfore are a little difficult to use sometimes.I can't speak about the sporran on Bears site It looks first class.

Have a look here before you make your mind up
http://www.sporrans.com
I think these are fab

All the best whichever you choose Murphy