Nathan,
A very well thought out and thought provoking post.I heartily agree with your comments.

One question though regarding traditions. As you say traditions are born and evolve constantly, so in years to come, how do the Rabble think wearing 'utility' kilts will be viewed? Will they still be seen as keeping the 'ancient' tradition of kilt wearing and Scottish culture alive? Will wearing such kilts, be they denim, leather, or what have you, be seen as a 21st century tradition mirroring the older traditions?

As you can see, your post has provoked my own thoughts...