I have two SportKilts. A Macdonald tartan and a Scot Skye. I've worn them to indoor conferences where I have to sit all day, and worn them to local concerts. Course I live in the boonies and most folks don't have a clue about a true kilt. Because they were tartans they're recognized as kilts...haven't had the "skirt comment" in a SportKilt yet.

Service initially was non-existant, though they eventually made things right and the last interaction went pretty smoothly. If you don't smoke you may need to wash whatever you get from them right away.

I haven't gotten around to doing it yet but removing the big logo patch may give a more authentic look...though it seems to help folks identify the Sportkilt as a kilt. I also understand from this board that some folks have their SportKilt pleats sewn down after they get it.

I like them for what they are, and having something in tartan did whet my appetite for ordering a hand sewn traditional kilt from Kathy's Kilts.

If you can afford it, go ahead and get one and see what you think. Do watch the length though, think they're all the same length.

Ron