Will, these both look fantastic - I have to say, I'd wear either. Call Me Doc has more of a "Ancient" look to me (as in the practice of mills using lighter colors, not that it looks older), while the HM 4 looks a little more Victorian Formal (darker, less busy). Given the choice ... I think I'd go with the HM 4, since I tend to like a darker tartan. But yes, I'd wear either with pride.

Are you planning a run on either of these? If so, please let me know - I'd love to reserve some fabric and have a kilt made (I promised no more new kilts, but I think I can sell the wife on this one )

Best,

Caleb