Added to my kilt collection.

[Jock Scot]

I have seen other posts like this one, showing pictures of this kind of garment - usually described as a utility kilt or the like.

Viewed from here in Scotland (through now aged and rather traditionally-focused eyes) I find myself perplexed. And my recurring response is 'But why..?'

I should add that I have never seeon one being worn here in Scotland, so I am guesing it is 'another culture' thing at play here.

There must be something fundamental in the idea and appeal of these so-called kilts, but what is the attraction or preference over a real kilt - and you all know very well what I mean by that!

Please do not misunderstand me. This is a genuine request for information and enlightenment.

Why would a man prefer a garment of this kind over a properly-made kilt in wool, or even synthetic materials that look the same?

The only reason I can imagine, is that they appeal to men who don't like tartan - but surely the tweed or hodden-grey kilts answer for that. The cut and wearing style makes me think they must be uncomfortable and awkward compared to a traditional kilt.

Is cost the issue?

But, to me, who often sees kilts of superior quality and excellent condition (I mean the eight-yarder in heavyweight wool) for sale in charity shops for £20-£40 (and sometimes much less) that cannot be the reason either.

If there is a definitive answer, or a check-list of preferences I am unaware of, could someone kindly help clear my bewilderment.

Before I get bombarded with 'Choice..!' responses, which I understand of course, I would like to know and understand why the preference, not just that there is one.

I have been perplexed by this same subject ever since I joined this website umpteen years ago. I have yet to receive an answer that I honestly comprehend. I await with interest for answers to your tactful post above. I think that I have only seen three of this type of garment in the wild, here in Scotland.

From long experience, this thread could head downhill pretty quickly, but honest and courteous explanations would be appreciated.