Quote Originally Posted by Planopiper
Do you think the other gentlemen there will be wearing tuxedos? If they'll be wearing suits, then the Argyll is probably more appropriate. It's certainly formal. And a good investment if you can see yourself wearing one in the future. If you want to invest in a Prince Charlie, that would be great, too, if you think you will get more use out of it. The Argyll is generally more useful, though.
Okay, from past events 99% of the attendees will be in a Tux or Gown. So I am leaning towards renting (hiring) a Prince Charlie as I really don't think that I would get much use out of it at home as I generally don't attend that many occasions that would require such a formal jacket.

However you raised an interesting question. Would it still be appropriate to wear an Argyll amongst all the tuxedos? Also, are dark kilt hose considered formal?

I would get much more use out of an Argyll at home and would be inclined to purchase one prior to my trip if it would be appropriate to wear to a black tie (not white tie) function. I have to say I also like the idea of buckles on the shoes rather than gillies as my Grandfather would always wear a pair on special occasions with his kit.

Thanks again to all for the comments and suggestions. I really appreciate them!

Brian Mackay