The debut of the Hiker was almost exactly one year ago, and they're doing quite well. It has its place... just (most likely) not with a normal "kilt" crowd.

The following comes from an owner of all three killts... AmeriKilt, Pittsburgh Kilts, and UtiliKilt.

The original AmeriKilt is a more "flexible" version of the UtiliKilt. The snaps in the front, the rear pocket and the storage capabilities are where the similarities end. The pleats are in the left-to-right layout that we're used to with casual kilts. The pleats are wider, but they're also easily maintained. The front apron is more similar to a casual kilt than the UtiliKilts', and is MUCH more comfortable in a kilt crowd. The front pocket sporran is the same (in looks) as the Pittsburgh Kilt, but does not have the two compartments. The rear pocket is also the same.

Material-wise, the AmeriKilts are known for being less rigid than UtiliKilts. This allows for a more comfortable sit, and a less encumbered feel. Unfortunately, the AmeriKilts do NOT have a truly finished hem... as they are not hemmed or selvedged. They won't fray, but they're not a New York Runway hit either.

As for the price, they are a fair deal. You have to buy them in the "pre-set" sizes, which does not allow for a whole lot of fit perfection. They DO allow you to order numerous combinations for waist, hips and length... but they're not quite as "tailored" as the Pittsburgh Kilt.

Here are some simple comparisons of the three:

AmeriKilt: great for casual wear and light work. Available in camos, solids, and different textures. The shipping and availability is pretty fast since they're pre-made. Cost is fair, and quality is good.

UtiliKilts: great for rugged wear and heavy work. Available in all sorts of styes and materials. The shipping and availability is all over the board. Cost is high and the quality can be excellant... especially for "pre-made" kilts.

Pittsburgh Kilts: wonderful for rugged or casual wear, and any sort of work... due primarily to the infinite materials and builds. Shipping and availability is outstanding for "custom-made" kilts. You can even help in the design of your own kilt vision. Cost is outstanding for a custom kilt, and the fit just can not be matched by a "pre-made" kilt.

Hope that helps until we get some more triple-owners to chime-in.