Look, there have been a LOT of great point made on this board. But I beleive that the original question is not whether this guy is selling kilts or not but rather would we buy one of these "under kilts". While I am not a big fan of the idea of me wearing one, I am all for someone else giving it a go.

These things appear a little too long and resrtictive for me. I like the idea of it being darker and being slit up the sides, purely out for reasons of practicality. But even if this were that case, I would personally not wear one. I don't like wearing anything under my kilt, and if I ever find a need to (ie. competing in the games or brisk weather) I turn to black boxer briefs for comfort, stealth, and retail availability.

So rock on if this is your bag. And if it's not, let's stay on topic and just say so. For me, it's not my bag. Discussing if the other things he sells should be called kilts should be saved for another string... but I think we have beat that subject to death already.