Hi Dave,

I do have both and adore each of them. Like any child they have their similarities and of course their own distinct personalities.

As far as the velcro vs. buckles no major problem, the velcro does seem to make it easier to put on, so when sleeping in a little bit, about 15 seconds faster to put on.

I have not noticed and "pilling" on the Stillwater nor have I on the USA.

They are both fine kilts and I have heard nothing but positives about either one. They are indeed both great kilts as far as the every day wear of kilts we all so want to do.

Hope this helps.