I think they are great if you are looking for something "Old Skool" to wear with your modern scottish clothing.

From a Reenactor standpoint they aint so hot. There are other cheaper dirks out there that are more authentic. And then there are the Glen McClain Dirks for 2-3 times what this guy charges. Nice thing about Glen's dirks is that you can really get the goat of museum folks. Nothing like walking up to a Curator and handing him an exact copy that Glen made of something thats supposedly on display and watch them deficate fired earth building materials.