Getting higher rank messages

**Iolaus** · 26th January 06, 01:45 PM

I agree with Ackwell. All this is doing is making people focus on their post counts - a complaint I've seen on other forums before. People that focus on the quantity of their posts, rather than the quality of their posts, will risk suffering from that well known disease, DOTM ("diarrhea of the mouth"). ;)

**GMan** · 26th January 06, 01:58 PM

Strange as it may sound Ackwell I agree with you. I too like to stress quality of the posts as opposed to quantity of posts, but I do feel that at times I need not be so focused on the intensity of posting, but to also have fun, and not think so much of myself (I do way too much of that).

**bubba** · 26th January 06, 02:03 PM

Just look at which forum it's in and skip Celebration Zone messages. It's been a bit out of hand lately but the new will wear off.

**mddock58** · 26th January 06, 02:05 PM

Personally I don't post, just to post.

All these things can be overused. Just like anything there are good reasons for doing this, but it can easily get overused.

Maybe we can acknowledge them, but lock it for keeping posts down.

Birthdays are different.

**Colin** · 26th January 06, 02:07 PM

I love the fact that all the posts in the Celebration Zone don't actually count towards a member's post count

I agree with you though Ackwell. I am finding it hard to find the quality posts buried within all the "way to go posts". I think it's great that some people are having fun, but it seems to be becoming a competition. Maybe Bubba's right and it's just the "new-ness" of that forum.

However when we start celebraing new kilt hose in celebratory post we will have likely gotten a bit out of hand.

**AckZel** · 26th January 06, 02:19 PM

Competing in post count is a very stupid thing. You are never going to catch Graham anyway! Can't you just admit your defeat!? ;)

**mddock58** · 26th January 06, 02:34 PM

I fully agree with you Ackwell.

The Posting Competition can get out of control, but that is not the idea behind this area.

The Forum is to promote wearing Kilts, and create bonds between all of us. Just as your recent post, where you asked us to respond to a personal area in your life, there are bonds that can be created.

This is a new section, and right now all are having fun with it.

It will settle down, or Hank will determine that some of it needs to change!

Our opinions and observations are welcome, without ridicule.

BTW - I don't remember if I wished you a Happy Birthday! :grin:

**AckZel** · 26th January 06, 02:44 PM

Originally Posted by mddock58

BTW - I don't remember if I wished you a Happy Birthday! :grin:

You did, but thanks again

**Mike S** · 26th January 06, 02:51 PM

I'm going to be a real grouch and agree here. I want to see the posts/threads with some "Meat" to them content wise when I log on to the new messages, not a bunch of "pat on the back" posts. And since it will be quite some time till I get a leg up rank wise, I'm feeling quite the Grinch.;)

By the way, isn't the staff somewhat worried that rank based on the number of posts is going to really boost the "me too" types of non-sense posts? As the Administrator of two very busy boards myself, I can attest to this real danger. Just a thought.