It looks like the Anderson tartan... the different color variations could be due to your monitor and/or the fact that different mills use different dyes in their different colors. Stewart of Appin Hntg from HOE and Strathmore are COMPLETELY different, but they're the exact same tartan.

The wool looks like "blanket weight" wool. It's a wool/felt blend which is "puffier" than $50/yard wool. Can you make a kilt from it? Yes. Will it look like a $500 kilt? never. I'm not trying to burst any bubbles... I'm not speaking to the skill of the maker, just the material itself.

It's the old saying... you get what you pay for. Is this wool blend an acceptable replacement for $50/yard wool? That's your call.

If you DO end up buying it, let me know what you think of the material and let me know if I'm right about the "puffiness" of it compared to HOE or Strathmore wool.