I Cant Make Up My Mind!!!!

[Colin]

Personally I like numbers 1 and 3

[Iolaus]

I like #1.

[Alan H]

#2 would make a killer Great Kilt.

for a modern kilt I vote for #3.

Take that red/pink stripe out of #4, though and I'm THERE

[Moosehead]

I kinda like the red in #4. Would look interesting pleated to the red stripe. The whole thing (minus the red) reminds me of the Grey Douglas.

[pdcorlis]

You really didn't think there would be some kind of consensus here did you? Personally I like #s 2 and 3. Best of luck!

[GlassMan]

I actually like #4 a lot. It's a nice serious looking tartan with just a hint of color. My 2nd choice would be #3.

[way2fractious]

My personal favorite is #4, which is a knockoff of Oban Grey (#1237) or Burberry Gray (#1239). There is an extra black stripe and white stripe and the red has been split into two; other than that it is extremely similar to the two named tartans.

[Eujeankilt]

You really didn't think there would be some kind of consensus here did you? Personally I like #s 2 and 3. Best of luck!

Must be a western US thing. I agree with Phil-two and three.

Dale

[Robin]

What we think isn't that important...just select the tartan you like.

After all...you'll wear it, you must like it

[McRod]

2 and 3 get my vote.but its up to you, go with whatever you feel is right.