Aye, I thoroughly enjoy Robertson's posts in Lallans. There's absolutely nothing wrong with it, even if English is the main language used on these forums. It's entertaining and educational. How many people have been educated on the difference between Scots and Gaelic simply by asking what in tarnation P1M is writing? How much flavor is added to X Marks by the posts? From my meagre studies of it, he's writing authentically enough and I don't think any of us know him well enough to say he's a "wannabe".