Hey Andrew!

Sounds like a good grouping to me. I just ordered leather sporran straps in chestnut and black, and a chestnut great kilt belt from cavscout. I'm taking the advice of all to ditch the chain except for formal occasions, which I don't see anytime soon.

As for simple being most tasteful, I'd have to say that, simple or elaborate, the tastefulness comes in how you combine all the pieces parts to bring off the look you're going for. I tend toward simplicity myself because I lack a good sense of style and color.