Yeah, not having to work around a bunch of stuff IS a definite plus. Black Watch would make a good choice for re-enacting early the early regimental period too. You should post up some pics of the brown based tartans... I think these look quite good myself, as a general rule. I like many of the weathered patterns on www.thescottishweaver.com because they have a lot of brown and grey in them. Could just be me... Have fun!