Wow....lots of choices and advice...where can I see the NYC tartan (let alone get one made out of it)....I have three sport kilts of my own and while they aren't truly the same thing, they have always gotten good reviews from those on the street. From them I was considering the armstrong, the hunting (U), or the Maclaren mod as well...I toyed with the nightstalked from Stillwater becuase I like the pattern however the length is 1.5" more than what would be proper while the Sport Kilt hits me at the right spot....the Henderson though is also a nice choice....grrrrrr....you aren't making this easy on me