When figuring out the double pleat, I was only calculating 20 pleats (a few less to save material, but I have noticed that based on how I wanted it pleated that the pleats really couldn't be any wider) and my measurement of 4.25" for the sett so I got 170" needed or about 1.5 yards more doing the math again just now (I only got a like 40" before, but I think I made a mistake). Part of my calculation was also based on my 5 yd only geing 4 yd 19 inches as well, with a 7" repeat, but I failed to account for the fact that it does not have the reverse pleat thus freeing up more tartan for the back as well. Still all in all I would have considered paying extra for that as an option.

And I'm not complaining about the depth of my pleats. You made it very clear that they were going to be shallow. All things considered, I am very happy that I got it pleated the way I wanted rather than have the extra 1/2" depth.

The apron was not a complaint, just facts. I think the taper is fine, just pointing out that different kiltmakers do things slightly differently.

As for the selvedge it would be less of a problem if it were at least even, but it wanders up and down slightly. However it that is how it is, then that is how it is.

I don't think you sounded defensive, not should you. This is a quality product, you do great work. I just try and be as honest as I can when reviewing a new kilt (rather than just blowing smoke) so others in the future can know exactly what they are getting. A saffron and the Welsh National are both very much in my sights (though probably not for 9 months or so, gotta buy other stuff as well).

Good job.

Adam