Personally, I think you look good.

I also think that some of the replies in this thread are a bit abrupt. The men that wrote them probably didn't mean for them to come off that way, but that's how they come off TO ME.

My two cents? Get some khaki or dark green kilt hose and wear the kilt with them.

Also, what Iused to do was fold my collar under and out of the way so it didn't get in the way of my neckerchief. It was literally folded completely beneath itself so that the entire collar was UNDER the rest of the shirt, on my shoulders. BSA used to make a v-neck, no collar shirt that worked well like this, but then you don't always wear the neckerchief and it looked kind of dumb without it.

nonetheless, you look proud of both your kilt AND your Scouting and for that...two thumbs up!