"Mini-kilt" is an oxymoron. A kilt has a correct length and anything else cannot be called a kilt any more than a thong or speedo can be called a pair of shorts. Whether or not a man would wear one is entirely up to him since it is not "men's attire" like a true kilt is. A kilt that is too short (like Martin mentions) or too long would be classified as improperly tailored or ill-fitting but still a kilt and still men's attire. To answer the question "would you buy a mini-kilt?" Yes, I would...for my daughters