Patrick, the debate wasnt about "cheapie" practice chanters, it was about P@kistani practice chanters, which as most half serious pipers know are rubbish.

Im all for "cheapie" chanters, subject to them playing the scale in tune and having a reed that doesnt squeal like a pig in a slaughterhouse . I cant see the point in paying a fortune for a PC, and Ive never tried a Walsh but ill take your word and id love to try one based on your reccomendation.