This one took me a couple of minutes to decide... I almost voted Nightstalker, I want to get one for my hubby. He currently has a Black Stewart and I have to admit, it's a very handsome tartan and I'd like to make sure he always has one (in case he outgrows this one too much or it gets too beat up to wear). I went with that one, especially since it's your favorite too! It is a nice one