Highland dress at court, 1921

[Scotus]

gilmore, what a wonderful source!

Todd, you must remember that for some people in this forum, tradition has little meaning. Old = bad and new = good.

there are times I'd prefer 1921.

Here, here!

[Jack Daw]

The list didn't seem so out of date to me. I've seen this at our Rabbie Burns Supper before (with pewter or chrome in place of silver probably). Carry on tradition, with acceptance of the modern, too. Variety is the spice of life.

[MacMillan of Rathdown]

Todd, you must remember that for some people in this forum, tradition has little meaning. Old = bad and new = good.

True, but then one does not invite those people to dinner. And that's the problem. They place themselves outside the mainstream by their refusal to follow traditional social forms, then complain about the fact that those who do follow "the rules" are snobs. What I find interesting is that, despite the sometimes heated comments on this forum, in the wider, off-line, kilted community probably 90% of the men attending kilted events are traditionalists.

The non-traditionalists (dare one say the "Round Haircuts"?) are in the distinct minority, and probably always will be.

[Scotus]

What I find interesting is that, despite the sometimes heated comments on this forum, in the wider, off-line, kilted community probably 90% of the men attending kilted events are traditionalists.

A most excellent point, and very true!

[thescot]

I hate being late to the party, but I must agree with Todd.

Of course, there is the fact that I could pull off almost every item of the court requirements from my current inventory.

On the other hand, the modern disdain for manners, fine dress, tradition, etc. is not to my personal liking. But then, that's the perogative of the aging.

[MartinGrenoble]

Sounds to me as if many people still regard the kilt as part of a costume rather than as a garment.

Martin

[MacMillan of Rathdown]

Sounds to me as if many people still regard the kilt as part of a costume rather than as a garment.

Martin

I think you may have mis-read, or perhaps mis-understood, my previous post. Traditionalists view the kilt as a garment. From personal observation it seems to me that it is the Round Haircut mob who are costumed, often as some sort of "protest" against the social norms of the vast majority of those who are kilted.

[Bugbear]

Round haircut...?
Are they doing that again?

What was the prefered haircut for this time period... 1921 and Highland dress at court?

[Southern Breeze]

Round haircut...?
Are they doing that again?

What was the prefered haircut for this time period... 1921 and Highland dress at court?

Odds are against it being the mohawk.

[gilmore]

...What I find interesting is that, despite the sometimes heated comments on this forum, in the wider, off-line, kilted community probably 90% of the men attending kilted events are traditionalists.

The non-traditionalists (dare one say the "Round Haircuts"?) are in the distinct minority, and probably always will be.

I don't know about that. While the events you and I would attend may be more likely to be gatherings of the traditional, my guess is that these are far, far outnumbered by kilted football fans, such as the Tartan Army, and others who wear kilts in pub crawls or other similar situations. Say what you will about them----that they buy cheap, Asian-made kilts that are ruining the market, that they don't know how to wear a kilt properly, etc---nonetheless, there are many more of them than of other kilted men.

And I don't know that that is altogether a bad thing. I welcome this increase in popularity of the kilt, even though how it is worn may not rise to our excrutiatingly correct standards. It's a sign that the health of the kilt as acceptable men's wear is doing well.