Besides the Caledonian Club Burns Supper, St Andrews pub does one, a bar called Iona in Brooklyn also. The Argyle Restaurant in Kearny NJ runs Burns Suppers for three weeks in January. I attended one at the Argyle on Friday, the Masonic Kilties one in East Hanover NJ on Saturday, and have another one coming up this Friday, also at a Masonic Lodge. Oh yeah, forgot the one last Thursday at the Copestone Lodge, also in Kearny NJ.
I'm sure Stewarts of Kearny located in Red Bank NJ also does one, and there are probably a few others throughout the area. Although not a Mason, I'm a piper in a "Scottish" pipe band and I guess we are bit more in the loop.