Great kilts in the American colonies

[Woodsheal]

Colonial America bottom line:

British soldiers in (military) highland dress - YES!

Civilians in traditional highland dress, especially post-1746 - NO!

Exception: Oglethorpe's highland immigrants in Georgia, 1730s-40s.

Of course, one can never say "never." You might, PERHAPS, have seen some civilians wearing highland garb in large Scots immigrant enclaves such as that in N. Carolina, though there are no period descriptions supporting this. But, since highland dress was not very adaptable to N. American conditions, the Scots - not being idiots! - would wear clothing that made sense. Even highland soldiers donned britches and leggings in huge numbers. Besides, the fact of the Proscription in the home country would preclude travelling to the New World in traditional dress. Maybe the odd tartan plaid or arisaid functioning as a blanket.

What WOULD be seen amongst New World highlanders: knit bonnets, dirks, perhaps the odd basket-hilt sword. I don't believe any tartan was being woven in the Colonies (except in Nova Scotia), so not many tartan plaids would be in use, except a small surviving number brought from the homeland, which would be used until worn out....

[macwilkin]

Colonial America bottom line:

British soldiers in (military) highland dress - YES!

Civilians in traditional highland dress, especially post-1746 - NO!

Exception: Oglethorpe's highland immigrants in Georgia, 1730s-40s.

Of course, one can never say "never." You might, PERHAPS, have seen some civilians wearing highland garb in large Scots immigrant enclaves such as that in N. Carolina, though there are no period descriptions supporting this. But, since highland dress was not very adaptable to N. American conditions, the Scots - not being idiots! - would wear clothing that made sense. Even highland soldiers donned britches and leggings in huge numbers. Besides, the fact of the Proscription in the home country would preclude travelling to the New World in traditional dress. Maybe the odd tartan plaid or arisaid functioning as a blanket.

What WOULD be seen amongst New World highlanders: knit bonnets, dirks, perhaps the odd basket-hilt sword. I don't believe any tartan was being woven in the Colonies (except in Nova Scotia), so not many tartan plaids would be in use, except a small surviving number brought from the homeland, which would be used until worn out....

Brian -- are you familiar with Duane Meyer's The Highland Scots of North Carolina? If anyone would have mention of contemporary sources mentioning Highland dress in the Cape Fear River settlements, it would be him. Dr. Meyer taught history for many years at my alma mater, although he retired my freshman year, more's the pity.

There were some loyalist regiments in the Revolution, such as the NC Highlanders, that wore the plaid, according to Stuart Reid's 18th Century Highlanders Plate F-3, pg. 42.

T.

[Woodsheal]

There were some loyalist regiments in the Revolution, such as the NC Highlanders, that wore the plaid, according to Stuart Reid's 18th Century Highlanders Plate F-3, pg. 42.

T.

True, but they weren't wearing their own (civilian) plaids, but were issued plaids, from royal storage, belonging to highland regiments such as the 71st, whose men were wearing philabegs on campaign.

I just don't think Iain's Jacobite look, w/ belted plaid, tartan waistcoat, targe - even white cockade, foresooth! - is anything that would have appeared in colonial N. America - other than in 1730s-40's Georgia (w/ black cockades) as mentioned above. Sorry, Iain...!