I was the fortunate winner of that jacket (though I didn't see your post until later). I suspect it is a bit short for me. Though it is correct in the shoulders, I notice that the arms are rather longer than the jacket sides. If I button it, my shirt shows above the kilt below the jacket and that seems wrong. I am a slender 5' 10" so it might fit a teenager best. I'll wear it a while before I give up on it. It was made by Alex Scott of Aberdeen (http://www.kiltmakers.co.uk/) in a style they no longer offer, but it is an attractive jacket, less green that the photo.