Tie or no tie?

[The Guy in the Kilt at UC]

It needs the tie because of the way the jacket looks. The epaulet makes the shoulder square, begging a formality that is just incomplete without a tie. It think it's why MoR likes the the non-tie look with a pullover. I agree with him, and I almost never wear a tie with sweater. Not that I wouldn't, I just haven't

[piperdbh]

Are you wearing the Crail with your kilt or with britches? If you wear it with the kilt, I agree that you need a tie. If you're wearing it with trousers, you'll look like waiter, since the Crail is shorter than a "regular" jacket.

[Bill]

Are you wearing the Crail with your kilt or with britches? If you wear it with the kilt, I agree that you need a tie. If you're wearing it with trousers, you'll look like waiter, since the Crail is shorter than a "regular" jacket.

No, I'm thinking only of the kilt. I just used the trousers as a descriptive tool to illustrate the look I was after.

Thanks for the response.

Slainte'

Bill