I have used both Batleys and HOE's cloth. They're both very nice... HOE has a proper kilting selvedge while batley uses a tuck selvedge (which is fine as well). For me, it would come down to a prefference in weight.

There's also a MacDonald Weathered by Lochcarron which is SIMILAR to the muted colors, but different.



Also, if you are interested in MacDonald Clanranald (only difference is a white 'box'), there are 2 more mills that produce Muted colors...

Marton Mills:


Strathmore: