Johnny Depp's Mad Hatter in a kilt

[Inchessi]

That guy is a great actor... I used to think he was odd... but in time, he has shown his talents..

I don't see the conflict, he is both. He is akin to Michel Keaton.
Keaton:
Mr. Mom vs. My So Called Life
Beetlejuice vs Batman
Johnny Dangerously vs. Desperate Measures

Depp

Ninth Gate vs Willy Wonka
What's eating Gilbert Grape vs. Pirates of the Caribbean