It's a hard decision. You're (thankfully) working with such classic designs that neither are outright offensive to the eye. However, my personal opinion is that #2 would be the better choice.

Just in terms of imagining myself with enough money to only buy two, I would painfully have to choose #3 to pass on. And I do mean painfully. I'm picturing #3 in brass or pewter over white goat hair (thinking of Duncan, Her Majesty's Keeper at Balmoral), and getting a sinking feeling that I may never see it come to pass.