My problem with articles such as these is that, while one may agree with the sentiments behind them, all-too-often they go much to far to make their case. The excerpt published here is a good case in point.

The statement is made that a kilt should have three straps and buckles, that the third strap is good practice, and that it allows for adjustment in size. Nonsense. The third strap serves absolutely no practical function, is just there for appearance, and I know many very traditional kiltmakers who routinely leave it off -- and I know many traditional kilt wearers who routinely request their kilts be made with only two straps.

Insisting that a true kilt, or real kilt, or authentic kilt or what have you must have three straps is a bit like insisting that it must have belt loops, or it must have a double fringe on the apron, because a single fringe just won't do, etc.

So, while I certainly can agree with the sentiment behind articles such as this, practically speaking, I have to disagree on certain points.